I design training systems for
hitters and pitchers and have studied this question extensively. Your statements about two
different energy systems, endurance (aerobic energy systems ) and speed (anaerobic
systems) is correct. But the number and timing of cuts is not determined by energy systems
alone. It is true that maximum benefit comes from taking the optimum number of swings.
A swing only demands power expenditure for approximately
1/6 of a second. Typical anaerobic energy reserves for fast twitch muscle fiber is 1.2-1.5
seconds of continuous maximal effort. Anaerobic recovery for short explosive events is
typically 6-10 seconds (ATP-PC re-synthesis).
This is what allows a pitcher to be throwing as hard
after 100 pitches a he was after the first 10.
Developing bat speed is as much a neural (brain-spinal)
telling the muscles to go fast as it is physiological (muscle becoming stronger).
Thats why looking bat speed training from an energy only perspective leads to less
than optimum training methods.
We find that a player (typical high school) bat speed
peaks after 15-20 swings (approximately 10 seconds between swings). Also the player can
take 3-6 sets of these swings and still maintain bat speed.
One of the main goals of this type of training is to
achieve 100% recruitment of fast twitch fiber. The body always tries to use the least
amount of energy when performing any muscular movement. It starts by recruiting the slow
muscles (burn the least amount of energy) first. Only when forced to be explosive does it
tap into its fast twitch muscles. Even then, it will only use the smallest number
necessary. to perform the task.
Also the body uses the most "familiar" neural
pathways to activate fibers.. This leads to the same muscle fibers used each time unless
you create an extra ordinary condition. An example of this is a person who suffers a
spinal injury being able to regain motor function by activating dormant pathways. One way
to achieve this in an athlete is to fatigue the "normally used fibers and force the
reserves to activate.
This is the same principle used in strength training.
Maximum strength/power gain occurs when you train to failure (can not complete any more
repetitions) with weights greater than 70% of your maximum voluntary contraction (you can
also train with lighter weights, i.e. ballistic training). Going to a sate of failure also
appears to be the fastest way to increase muscle size/density (muscle strength).
There is also another very important variable called
periodization (how many swings over what period of time). You must train at sustained
levels for an extended period of time and then give the body a chance to recover. Here we
are talking about time frames spanning several weeks of training.
Swing training should be divided into two categories,
power and technique (skill). Power training requires stressing the body to a point of
decreased bat speed. Technique requires staying at maximum bat speed. The two need to be
separated (de-coupled). Always do technique training before power training. We recommend
swing power training 3 times a week starting 6-12 weeks before the season begins. And then
maintenance there after.
One of the most important aspects of power training is to
vary the loading (over load and under load training). Also the range of loading is very
important. Obviously maintaining good form and technique is important. Typically using
three different swing loads, we find 150 to 200 swings in a power session (high school age
player) leads to maximum results.
Using these techniques we have taken high school players
from a starting speed of 65 MPH to 95 MPH in 8-12 weeks.
One other comment. I think Jeannie made the statement in
a previous posting about a player with high bat speed but could not hit in a game
situation and questioned the value of high bat speed. Some people are blessed with natural
ability to generate high speeds but lack control and timing. One additional benefit of
swing training (if done correctly) is the bat control and timing improves significantly
(if done correctly).
You are very correct in the part mental stimulus plays in
training. We have used feedback techniques to with great success (result-goal
stimulation).
Recently we had a personal trainer call us who was
working with several Major League players (prior to spring training). We had sent him some
equipment several weeks earlier. He was calling to ask what was a good bat speed for a
pro. I told him 90 MPH or over is getting up there. He told me that when the players first
started, their bat speed was 92-94 MPH After 20 days of training they were averaging
105-107 MPH. He was surprised that players already at a high level could add so much in a
short period of time. We see this effect all the time. This shows how important mental
stimulus is to training for maximum effort
Hope this was not too winded or technical, but this is an
area that I have some first hand experience and deserves a fuller explanation Comments and
alternate views are welcomed.